Posts tagged "adoption"
Are Birth Moms Considered Moms?
This is an interesting opinion piece by Meika Rouda, who writes great articles for The Next Family. In this particular article, she considers the following quote found on a birthmother support website:
“When I am talking to another birth mom, I’m not a birth mom, I’m a mom. We don’t have to put a title on it. I can say ‘Oh my son did this or my daughter did this‘ and I can just be a mom. There are no stipulations on it, there’s no stigma. We can just be moms.”
She goes on to say that she thinks “…it is dangerous thinking for birthmothers to be sitting around talking about the children they placed like they’re the ones mothering them. It is a different job and one that adoptive moms should get the credit for.”
I don’t think that’s what this particular birthmom was saying - I think she was saying that she can be proud of her child’s accomplishments without having to explain the dynamic of their relationship (or lack of one, depending on their situation). I don’t believe she was trying to suggest that she was mothering her child at all.
Regardless of what that birthmom was trying to say, it’s the author’s suggestion that “credit” is due to anyone that bothers me the most.
Read More
“My Grandpa died when my mom was very young. My Grandma (swiftly) remarried who my mom would call "Dad". He never formally adopted her - but I think that's more because we're talking 50 years ago. My mom experienced several times of people commenting about how there was "no mistaking" they were family. My Grandpa would always just wink at my mom. There was no disrespect to my real Grandpa - just a special inside secret. How do you think your daughter might feel about those comments as she grows?”
—the--kel--smith
(Question in response to an earlier post.)
I love this story! I think I feel the same way as they must have whenever someone who doesn’t know that I’m not D’s biological mother comments on our lookalikedness - like it’s a special inside secret, and I hope that’s the way Dictator will feel about it. I hope that she feels a sense of belonging or pride when people comment on how much she looks like us.
What I fear, though, is that those comments will highlight any sense of differentness she might feel. I worry that she may feel disloyal to her birthparents (who she definitely looks like) by accepting comments about our family resemblance, and I worry that she may feel disloyal to us if she points out that any resemblance is purely by chance. I worry that if she’s at all sensitive about being adopted, those comments will get right under her skin and heighten those sensitivities.
I hope they’re a non-issue for her. I hope she gives me a conspiratorial little wink and accepts those comments graciously, then moves on.
But I worry. Occupational hazard, I guess.
nickyhawkins:
I have found that people like to point out things that are similar between Dipper and I. Like “Oh she has blonde hair like you!” or “You both have hands.” And I know that they mean well but sometimes I get annoyed thinking that they are trying to reassure me that I am her mother or that we actually do belong together. Is this common for other adoptive parents? Am I the only grouch that gets annoyed by it? Is it because she and I are both white? If we were different races would this happen? We really dont look alike at all. She is like a tiny blonde princess fairy and I am a dirty blonde troll.
…
We get this all the time, and to be fair, Dictator looks a lot like I did as a kid. I love the comparisons when they come from people who don’t know that she was adopted, because then it’s truly just an observation and I get to relish in the knowledge that someone thinks my kid looks like me.
When the comments come from people who do know that Dictator was adopted, it’s a little different. I think I’m always on the lookout for a note of that “reassurance” that nickyhawkins talks about above, or people saying it to somehow dismiss or ignore the fact that D was adopted. It’s totally my issue, not theirs, and I know it. But it still gets under my skin.
I am not, however oddly, offended when people say, “I just can’t get over how much she looks like you! What are the odds?” or something to that affect. For some reason, the mere fact that someone who says it like that (essentially acknowledging the role adoption played in our lives) makes it okay for me.
…So, yeah. Talking out of both sides of my mouth since 1980.
choosingadoption:
I’m talking to my case worker about being able to talk to other people who are considering placing and talking to adoptive parents before they get their books together for the agency. I don’t think Zakk will be interested in doing it since he’s so private about the adoption but it’s something I definitely want to do. I’ve gotten to talk to a lot of people through this blog and if I can help anyone else in another way, I want to be able to do it! Whether it’s fellow birth moms, or adoptive parents, I want a part in it!
This was by far the most interesting and informative part of the entire adoption education process for me – meeting and talking to birthmothers and adoptive parents who have been through it all (not to mention that it was a much-needed break from listening to the agency’s director talk about statistics and processes for two and a half straight days).
After Dictator was born, we had an opportunity to speak to a group of prospective adoptive parents at an education seminar, and it was really cool to be the couple with the happy baby sitting at the front of the room answering their questions. (Of course, when asked some questions about openness, we answered honestly about our experience and our situation, including the text from birthmom the night Dictator was born. Oddly, despite the fact that we stressed repeatedly that our situation was unusual and not right for everyone, the agency never asked us to return… Hm.)
I also know that Dictator’s birthmother talked to other pregnant women privately at the agency’s request, which seemed to be very therapeutic for her (and I’m sure, very helpful for the women who came to the agency to talk about their options).
So, to Kelsey: I’m glad you’re sharing your story. You have the opportunity to help people on all sides of adoption, and that’s so important.
To other people involved in adoption: Did you talk to other prospective birth- or adoptive parents before choosing adoption? Was it particularly helpful, not worth the time, etc.?
(For some reason, I can’t enable answers on this post, but ask is open and anon is on!)
Names
waitingformaybebaby:
We are curious… For all the birth parents and adoptive parents out there: Who picked the baby’s name? Any special reason? Any arguments about who got to choose? Just wondering….
Ready for a long story?
Read More
Walking Contradiction
We’re off to visit Dictator’s birth families this weekend. Dictator has been counting sleeps since Monday, asking approximately every 23 waking minutes whether it’s time to go yet.
The bags are packed, the snacks and DVD player are ready for the drive…
“I can’t want to go, Mama.”
“What's been the thing that surprised you the most about adopting? If there was one thing you could tell people who were on the fence about an open adoption, what would it be?”
—viaukraineAlways with the hard questions! I must have answered the second part of your question three times before I settled on what I’m posting, and I’m still not happy with the answer.
What surprised me most about adopting… That’s a really tough one. I think I was prepared for it to take significantly longer than it did to develop a relationship and feel entirely comfortable with Dictator’s birthparents, so it was surprising to find that within a few weeks, they felt like old friends and that within a few months, they felt like family. I am still surprised by how many people have negative opinions about adoption (or about our adoption and related choices), but then again, there are jerks everywhere, so I shouldn’t let people surprise me…
The one thing I’d tell people who are on the fence about open adoption? Don’t do it. If you’ve done the research and talked to people involved in all sides of open adoption and you’re still on the fence, do. not. do. it.
Does that sound harsh?
What I mean is, if you’re anything less than wholly accepting of the idea that an open adoption means contact between your family and your child’s birthparents, then open adoption is not for you. Scratch that – it’s more than acceptance; it’s about actually desiring ongoing contact with your child’s birthparents. If the “open” part of an open adoption is just something you’ll just “deal” with in order to have a baby, think long and hard before entering that arrangement.
Of course, this is the same thing I would say someone who was on the fence about having a baby at all – don’t do it until you’re sure. Someone on Tumblr once shared this analogy: Having a baby is like having a giant face tattoo; you’d better be 100% sure that you’re ready to live with it for the rest of your life. Same goes for open adoption; not only are you inviting a child into your home, but also his birthmother (at least) or birth families (if you’re lucky). You’d better be sure you’re willing to live with those extra people and the ramifications of having them in your life before you invite them into it.
BUT – if you’re on the fence and you’ve yet to do research or talk to people involved in open adoptions, make sure you take those steps first, because ultimately, open adoption? So worth it.
Today is the last day of National Adoption Awareness Month – Ask me anything! Or read what I’ve already written about adoption.
Last Call! (Not Really)
Tomorrow marks the end of National Adoption Awareness Month. I’ve loved answering your adoption questions and hope this doesn’t necessarily mark the end of them!
So… Ask me anything, or check out what I’ve already written about adoption.
mediocremommy:
In honor of National Adoption Awareness Month I decided to re-post something I wrote last year…
My little boy is getting so big. He knows all his letters, he can count to 20, he can dress himself (I have no idea if all newly made 3 year olds can do this or not but I’m naturally assuming he is…
A post from one of my favourite Tumblr-ers Tumblrs Tumblrites people. This is the first post of hers that I ever read, and I promise, it’s a gooder. Click through to read the whole post.
It’s National Adoption Awareness Month. Ask me anything!
“I'm one of your new followers but I don't want anyone to see who I am because only a couple of people know I'm pregnant and giving my baby up. I like how your relationship is with DIctator's birthparents and I want that too. Do you have any advice for how to get that?”
—AnonymousHi! Thanks for the follow!
Let me first say that you need support. If only a few people know about your pregnancy and adoption plan, make sure that those people are the kind that will support you throughout the entire process. It’s hard, which I’m sure you know already, and I don’t think it’s healthy to go it alone or with people who are not supportive of your choices.
My advice from an openness perspective is this: Know what you want, know your motivations for what you want, ask for it, and find people who feel the same way.
I highly recommend finding an agency or a lawyer who understands what you want and who supports open adoption, one that is willing to show you multiple files so that you can find prospective adoptive parents who you can see yourself building a lifelong relationship with.
Then once you’ve found them, get to know them.
Ask questions.
Find out what they want in an open adoption.
Basically – date.
If you find that open adoption means different things to each of you, walk away. If you don’t think you could spend the rest of your life with these people in it, walk away. Don’t feel obligated to go with the first people you meet, but don’t string them along if you’re not sure, either. The right adoptive family for you and your baby exists; you just have to find them.
Once you’ve established your level of contact and the placement is complete, reach out, but respect boundaries. This isn’t a one-way street in any regard, so make sure they respect your boundaries, too. Treat each other well; you’re in this together and for the long haul, and the way you treat each other will determine how good your relationship is for the rest of your lives.
Good luck.
It’s National Adoption Awareness Month. Ask me anything!
“I can't believe how rude some people are being to you about this. I honestly haven't had one douchebag question yet. Maybe it's because they think Canadians are nice? Anyway, I just wanted to tell you I have never got the sense that you think you're special or better than anyone for having adopted. And, in the spirit of National Adoption Month Questions: If you were to adopt again would you insist on a birth family that wanted at least the same amount of contact as Dictator's?”
—viaukraineLucky you… I’m guessing by the grammar that it’s one person, and I think I know who this particular douchebag is. I honestly don’t know why I keep answering her questions, except that they usually make her look more like an asshat than they make me feel bad, so… Is that particularly small of me? Probably. Do I care? Not much. (Maybe I’m the douchebag.)
Thank you for your kind words. It would kind of horrify me to think that people actually felt that I thought I was better than anyone for having adopted (I don’t much care about the opinion of one asshat anon).
If we did adopt again, yes, we would absolutely seek the same level of contact. It would devastate me to adopt another child and have him wonder why his birthparents are less involved than his sister’s, because no matter how well we manage it, that’s going to affect his self-worth. It just will.
This is actually the main reason we’re unlikely to adopt again – we recognize that we have an exceptional relationship with Dictator’s birthparents, and I don’t believe that we’d ever find that again. Could we insist on it? Sure, but who wants to fight for a relationship when one party isn’t interested in it? I can’t imagine how exhausting that would be, and how unnatural it would feel for everyone involved.
This does make me curious about those who have adopted multiple children (or adoptees with multiple siblings) – do your children all have similar contact with their birthparents? If not, how does this affect your kids (does it affect your kids)? How do you deal with their feelings about that?
It’s National Adoption Awareness Month. Ask me anything!
“What made you want to adopt in the first place (if that isn't too personal of a question)?”
—privatetaliaIf you can’t tell already, I’m kind of an open book!
Like a lot of people, I always knew I wanted children, but I never gave much thought to how they would come into my life. Had I loved a man who could produce kids, I’d probably have gotten knocked up a few times by now; but I didn’t. I love a man who knew from a very early age that it was extraordinarily unlikely that he would ever have biological children, so when we were ready to have kids, we had a few options: the usual invasive procedures, donor sperm or adoption.
I had a very hard time considering donor sperm, even though the Husband was perfectly fine with it. I wanted a child that was equally “ours” – either biologically 100% us or biologically 0% us. I think I was afraid that the Husband might feel disconnected from a child that wasn’t “his” if we went with donor sperm and my eggs. (I’ve since realized how stupid that fear was, and we were actually reconsidering donor insemination shortly before we got the call that Dictator’s birthparents wanted to meet us.)
We were never interested in IVF. There was no guarantee that it would work and we didn’t want to spend that kind of money on procedures that might be fruitless. Besides, biological children just weren’t that important to us.
But adoption – adoption sounded perfect to us. It’s relatively inexpensive where we live, the wait times didn’t turn us off completely, and while we were waiting, we weren’t going to be constantly schlepping to the doctor’s office, dealing with hormones, etc. Adoption didn’t address my desire to be pregnant, but at the end of the day, it wasn’t about bearing children; it was about raising them.
I talk about this a little bit here, but I think that because we always knew that the Husband wasn’t likely to produce kids, we had a head start on considering other options; it wasn’t a giant shocker one day after trying for ages to conceive. We’d had a long time to consider how we would start our family (we were 18 when we started dating, and he shared with me early on that he couldn’t have kids), so I think we’d kind of made our decision well before we really had to.
It’s National Adoption Awareness Month. Ask me anything!
“What will you do when it turns out you were wrong and your daughter grows up confused by having her real parents around so much?”
—AnonymousThen we’ll add it to all the other things we’re bound to screw up in this fake-it-till-you-make-it role of parenthood, because let’s face it - we haven’t got a bloody clue whether we’re doing anything right.
That said, we believe that having a relationship with her birthparents will ultimately be healthier for Dictator than simply knowing she’s adopted but not knowing where she came from. We’re doing what we think is best for her, and if that screws her up in the end, we’ll pay the therapy bills.
But I don’t think this is what she’ll be talking to her therapist about (we’ll give her much more fodder for that, I’m sure!), because this is just her reality. This is her family, and although it’s different from “traditional” families, I’m really not sure what’s traditional anymore.
By the way, there’s nothing fake about me, so go easy on phrases like “real parents”, okay?
It’s National Adoption Awareness Month. Ask me anything!